profile

Emily Cretella / Cursive Content

10 School Storytelling Pitfalls 📉 to Avoid Next School Year

Published about 1 month ago • 1 min read

July 2026

The Story Starter

Reader,

Storytelling is at the heart of your school’s marketing success. It’s how you connect with prospective families, engage current ones, and show the world what makes your school unique. But sometimes, even the best intentions can lead to stories that fall flat—or worse, create a disconnect with your audience.

Are you making any of the 10 common school storytelling mistakes?

These missteps can weaken your message, confuse your audience, and ultimately keep your stories from having the impact they deserve. Don’t worry, though—once you spot these mistakes, they’re easy to fix!

​This post dives into the storytelling pitfalls schools often face and how to avoid them. From telling stories that focus too much on your school and not enough on your audience, to ignoring the power of visuals, it’s full of insights that will help you craft stories that truly resonate.

Keep creating and sharing your school’s best stories,

Emily

This week's storytelling tip:

Stay audience-focused. It’s tempting to center your stories around your school, but remember—your audience wants to see themselves in what you share. Make them the hero of the story.

Your school has a powerful story to tell. You just need help telling it.

Let's turn your school's expertise, differentiators, outcomes, legacy, and vision into one cohesive school story that attracts dream families, increases inquiries & enrollment, strengthens communities, and grows school influence.

See you next week!

Remember: as a Cursive Insider, you have access to our FREE Resource Library​
​Unsubscribe | Update your profile | P.O. Box 854, North Haven, CT 06473

Emily Cretella / Cursive Content

School Storyteller for Independent Schools

Cursive Content helps independent school marketers tell powerful stories that attract dream families, increase inquiries & enrollment, strengthen communities, and grow school influence. Subscribe for weekly content and storytelling tips!

Read more from Emily Cretella / Cursive Content

August 2026 The Story Starter Reader, Last week, I wrote about how AI reads your website (short version: in pieces, not top to bottom, and your Google ranking doesn't guarantee it likes what it finds). This week answers the question: does this mean we have to write differently? Yes. Just not the way people assume. You don't need to start writing like a spec sheet. What needs to change is where the specific facts — dates, numbers, formats — live on the page. This week's post walks through...

about 3 hours ago • 1 min read

August 2026 The Story Starter Reader, If you've been here a while, you know that I've been sharing school website copywriting best practices for ... quite some time. (Decades, actually.) Which is why this week's topic is so important. It's about AI search — and specifically, how AI reads your website and determines what (and if) it will share. I spent the last few weeks down a research rabbit hole, and I'll be sharing my findings, thoughts, and tips in a series of blog posts. This week's is...

7 days ago • 2 min read

August 2026 The Story Starter Reader, "Yes, that's definitely on our list ... we just need time to focus on it." Sound familiar? The idea of putting a new marketing endeavor (like digital advertising) "on our list" is both comforting and dangerous. Comforting because we acknowledge that it is important -- but dangerous because it's SO EASY to keep pushing it off until next week, next semester, or next school year. This is why I'm incredibly excited to share something exclusively with Cursive...

15 days ago • 1 min read